9 Essential Strategies for Selecting Tenants for Your Rental Property

Enrique V Urdaneta


Maximizing Your Income Through Careful Tenant Selection

Investing in rental properties primarily aims to generate a steady income stream. However, many investors, fixated on the numbers, often overlook one of the most crucial factors in achieving this goal: selecting the right tenant. The consequence is often delayed rent payments and property damage. Here are nine essential strategies to help you select the best tenants for your property.

1. Verify Candidates' Financial History

It's crucial to verify a candidate's financial solvency to ensure timely rent payments. How can this be done? Request proof of monthly income and check their credit score. Those with low credit scores often have a history of delinquency in payments, which can jeopardize your income.

2. Check Criminal Backgrounds

Reviewing applicants' criminal backgrounds is essential to ensure the safety of your property. This information can be obtained by consulting public records or directly requesting a police report from the candidate.

3. Request References from Previous Landlords

It's recommended to ask for contact information from at least two previous landlords. Inquire about the candidate's behavior as a tenant and neighbor, as well as their rent payment history, to get a clear idea of their reliability.

4. Understand Their Reasons for Moving

Inquiring about the candidate's reasons for moving can be an effective strategy to identify potential issues. Were they evicted? Or do they have a solid justification for the change?

5. Confirm Employment History

A history of frequent job changes could indicate employment instability, which might affect their ability to pay rent on time. Therefore, it's important to verify their employment history.

6. Trust Your Intuition

Even if all documents seem satisfactory, if your intuition tells you something is off with the candidate, it might be best to consider other options.

7. Comply with the Federal Fair Housing Act

It's essential to remember that it is illegal to discriminate against applicants based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex, disability, or familial status, according to the Federal Fair Housing Act. Ensure you respect this law throughout the selection process.

8. Create a Solid Lease Agreement

After selecting the right tenant, the next crucial step is drafting an effective lease agreement. This contract should cover all bases, including the rent amount, terms and conditions, tenant responsibilities, and policies for renewal and cancellation, among other things. Having a solid lease not only provides legal security but also helps avoid future misunderstandings.

9. Maintain the Property

As a landlord, it is crucial to keep the property in good condition. This not only helps retain current tenants but also attracts new ones. Schedule regular inspections, respond to maintenance requests promptly, and carry out necessary repairs to ensure the property remains in good shape.


Selecting the right tenant can make a significant difference in the success of your real estate investment. Consider these tips when selecting your future tenants, and you will increase your chances of obtaining a stable income stream and avoid many common issues that rental property owners often face.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. How can I verify an applicant's financial history? To verify an applicant's financial history, you can request proof of their monthly income and check their credit score. This can include pay stubs, bank statements, tax returns, or other documents that demonstrate their solvency. You can also require a credit check to evaluate their financial responsibility.
  2. Is it legal to request a police report from prospective tenants? Yes, it is legal, as long as the privacy laws of the country or state in question are respected. You must obtain the applicant's consent before conducting any background checks. It's important to note that laws vary from place to place, so it's always advisable to consult with a lawyer or real estate expert.
  3. What should I ask previous landlords when requesting references? Some questions you can ask are: Did the tenant pay rent on time? Were there any complaints from neighbors? Did the tenant take care of the property and leave it in good condition when they moved out? Were there any disputes or legal issues?
  4. Why is it important to know an applicant's reasons for moving? Knowing their reasons for moving can provide clues about potential future problems. If the tenant has been previously evicted or had conflicts with past landlords, they could be a risk. Conversely, reasons like a new job or the need for more space are reasonable explanations for moving.
  5. What does the Federal Fair Housing Act say about discrimination in rental properties? The Federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination in the sale, rental, or negotiation of housing based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, or disability. This means landlords cannot refuse to rent, set different terms or conditions, or provide different services or facilities based on these characteristics.


Enrique Vicente Urdaneta

Real Estate Advisor | eXp Realty | EVU Luxury Homes


[email protected]




Disclaimer: The information presented in this article is intended to provide a general understanding of the topic. However, please note that I am a real estate agent, not a lawyer, accountant, tax, or financial advisor. This content should not be taken as legal, tax, accounting, or financial advice. The laws and regulations related to this topic can be complex and may change or expand in the future. Therefore, it is crucial to consult with a qualified professional, such as a specialized financial or tax advisor, before making any decision based on this information. As a real estate agent, I can provide various options and professional guidance related to the real estate aspects of your investment strategy, and for matters related to tax implications, legal issues, and financial planning, please consult with the appropriate professionals, which whom I have allies I can refer.

¿Eres Agente de Bienes Raíces y Hablas Español? Únete a nuestro equipo

Asóciese conmigo y obtendrá coaching GRATUITO sobre bienes raíces, ventas y marketing en español

Are you a Real Estate Agent and do you speak Spanish? Join our team

Partner with us and get FREE real estate, sales, and marketing coaching in Spanish
*Please note the training is entirely in Spanish.*

Follow Me on Instagram